A Guide to Buying Vintage T-Shirts at Thrift Stores and on eBay

dsc_0380.jpgThis guide is to help you find and buy vintage t-shirts at a reasonable price and for regular wear. If you’re thinking about adding vintage t-shirts to your wardrobe or want to better appreciate the ones you already have, read on.

We ship a lot of vintage t-shirts every month. If you want to get some in the mail, subscribe to Comma, Vintage today.


Glossary of Vintage T-Shirt Terms

50/50 or FIFTY-FIFTY: This describes t-shirts made from a blend of equal parts cotton and polyester. They’re not uncommonI find 50/50 t-shirts more commonly than 100% cotton ones–but it’s often used in listings and so worth knowing.

DEADSTOCK: Deadstock refers to a t-shirt in new and unworn condition. Among vintage items, deadstock t-shirts are relatively common. Chances are they sat untouched in a screen-printers inventory for decades before being donated or sold.

Because they were not often individually tagged or packaged, determining whether a piece is deadstock requires some sleuthing:

  • Smooth seams: On a shirt that has been washed, the seams will often cinch up, creating a bit of a ripple at the hem, neck, and shoulders.
  • Crisp tag: The tags on many vintage t-shirts are made of a stiff, papery material. These tags degrade quickly after washing.
  • Found in bulk: If you find 7 or 70 identical t-shirts together, it’s likely that they’re unworn. Printers often liquidate inventory in lots rather than as individual pieces.

Use of the term “deadstock” seems to me a bit more lenient in vintage t-shirt sales than in jeans or sneakers. I endorse use of the term so long as condition is reasonably deduced.

It’s a different calculus than with Jordans or Levi’s, of course: Many deadstock t-shirts are being sold for daily wear and can be had for less than $20.

IRON-ON HEAT TRANSFER: An iron-on graphic is exactly what it sounds like: An image or text transferred to the fabric using heat. They are subject to peeling and cracking, and don’t hold up well to numerous washes. On the flip side, they often feature photographs and detail difficult to otherwise put on a t-shirt. And  vintage iron-on graphics can be bought unused and newly applied to any t-shirt you please.

MOUNTED COLLAR: A mounted collar is sewn onto the top of the t-shirt, rather than sewn under the fabric. In my experience, mounted collars hold their shape better than sewn-under ones.

An older vintage t-shirt–from the 1960s, for example–is more likely to have a mounted collar than one from the 1980s or 1990s. So, do a double check if you see one in the wild. Of course, Russell Athletic still mounts collars in 2018.

PAPER THIN: This term is used to describe t-shirts that are particularly well-worn and soft. A common practice of proof is hold the shirt up to a light. I tried my best below, though there are much thinner shirts in the world.

RINGER: A ringer has different colored collar and cuffs made from a ribbed material. They offer a distinctively vintage look.


Take 25% off your first shipment with code “TEESHIRTS.”CTA button (7)


SCREEN PRINTED: In screen printing, an inky medium is pressed through a screen and onto the t-shirt. Because the process requires a moderately laborious set up, many vintage screen printed t-shirts–especially those from small events or local institutions–feature only one or two colors.

“SELVAGE POCKET:” Many sellers erroneously use this term to describe the reinforcement tape used within the pockets of many vintage t-shirts. The fabric is not selvage in the least. But-shirts with reinforced pockets tend to be of good age and quality, so it’s useful term to know.

SINGLE STITCH: Single stitch refers to the prevalent mode of construction in vintage t-shirts. Specifically, it refers to the finishing on the cuff, hem, and shoulder of the t-shirt, where a single line of stitching secures the fabric edge. On most contemporary t-shirts–your standard Gildan, for example–a double row of stitching is used.

When thrifting, you might scan the t-shirt rack cuff by cuff rather than flipping through every single hanger. It’s a time saver.

Of course, not every interesting vintage t-shirt is single stitch, and not every single stitch t-shirt is truly vintage. A number of brands use single stitch construction to replicate the vintage look. And many vintage shirts, especially those from the 90s, may not be single stitched throughout.

THRASHED: Thrashed is the go-to term to describe a shirt that’s heavily worn but still wearable. The fabric will be thin, there may be holes and tears, and there may be stains. I don’t have any thrashed t-shirts in my collection, but the screen capture below illustrates the concept:

Generally, the damage is from frequent washing and wear: Discolored collars, holes at the shoulders, and frayed hems are common. Natural fading and repairs are often desired. A giant wine stain on the front does not contribute to thrashiness.

TRI-BLEND: Tri-blend refers to vintage t-shirts made from from cotton, polyester, and rayon fabric.  These t-shirts are desirable for their rarity, softness and durability. The yarns are often heathered, giving the fabric a unique, variegated look.

TUBULAR KNIT (OR, CIRCULAR KNIT): Circular knit t-shirts are made from fabric knit into a tube shape. As a result, t-shirts made with circular knit fabric lack side seams. In my experience, tubular knit t-shirts drape more fluidly and more naturally than shirts with side seams.

Please note that circular knit does not mean loop-wheeled. It’s a bit of a frog and toad scenario: Loop wheeled fabrics are made on a particular kind of vintage circular knitting machine. You can read more about loopwheeled fabrics at Heddel’s, though understand that circular knitting is still done on an industrial scale in 2018.


CATALOG OF BRANDS AND TAGS

There are, to be certain, dozens of vintage t-shirt brands. But some are more common than others. Below is a catalog of comma tags I’ve come across, as well as approximate dates of production.

The only certain way to date a vintage t-shirt is to have a date attached to the graphic. When we find multiple t-shirts with the same tag but different printed dates, we can reasonably estimate a range of production for all shirts with that tag. So, if we find a shirt with a given tag but no visible date, we can roughly determine its age.

1970s:

1980s:

1990s

This list is not exhaustive, nor do I insist on precision. I hope to add to it over time.


Take 25% off your first shipment with code “TEESHIRTS.”

CTA button (7)


SIZING

When looking for vintage t-shirts, the size on the tag is, for the most part, arbitrary. I wear a small in 90% of contemporary brands. My personal vintage t-shirt collection ranges from small to extra large, and they all fit about the same.

The photo on the left shows shirts tagged “Extra Large.” Note how they vary in width. The photo on the right shows shirts tagged “Large.” Note how they vary in length.

Generally speaking, the size of a shirt relative to its tagged size has increased over time. That is to say, a large from 1995 will be bigger than a large from 1975. There’s plenty of anthropological explanations for this, but I’m not qualified to investigate them.

It’s more important to understand shrinkage. If you find a vintage t-shirt in deadstock condition, prepare for it to shrink considerably. 100% cotton t-shirts will shrink more than polyester blends.

When thrifting, take time to search a size above what you normally wear. There may be pieces that fit quite well. When buying online, look for accurate measurements of length, shoulder width, and chest width (pit to pit).


Final Thoughts

At once ubiquitous and unique, t-shirts are great gateway to the world of vintage clothing. They offer styles and stories and fits as various their owners. I’m hoping this guide can help you take the leap.

If you want to learn more about the world of vintage t-shirt collecting, I recommend exploring the Defunkd Vintage T-Shirt Collective.  There’s a lot of awesome, timeless content there.

You can also check out the books Rap Tees or Vintage T-Shirts for some cool photos and history.

But if you need further incentive, please know that the global t-shirt economy is one of the most wasteful and exploitative on Earth. Buying used t-shirts helps, in a tiny but meaningful way, to counter emissions, improper chemical disposal, and human exploitation, not to mention the literal waste of discarded t-shirts.

4 thoughts on “A Guide to Buying Vintage T-Shirts at Thrift Stores and on eBay

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s